Wednesday, 20 May 2015

Old Boy

Positive Western Reception:

  • cult reception
  • complex narrative
  • symbolism of eating the live octopus
  • powerful film - depths of the human heart
  • age consent 

Negative Western Reception:
  • harming animals - octopus     
  • sadmasochism 
  • puerile
  • does not match the standards of a puritanical majority (christian)
  • age consent - America has a higher consent age than Korea
  • style over substance
  • adolescent audience 

Hollywood Reception:
  • CHN
  • commodifies morals 
  • alignment - make the audience sympathise him and give him longer backstory
  • happy ending different

Thursday, 14 May 2015

Old Boy


  • Provocative film; deals with incest and violence 
  • Central imagining 
  • Freud oedpial complex


Wednesday, 22 April 2015

How would a black spectator react to Django Unchained?

Tarantino's Django Unchained explores the freeing of a black slave named Django by a white bounty hunter known as Dr. Schultz.

Bell Hook's theory of the black gaze describes an overwhelming desire to look. Whilst black people always realised that mass media maintained white supremacy, presenting white people as the dominant and black people as the inferior.

A spectator may take on a negotiated reading of the film by adapting to the black gaze. For example, we may see alignment with the other black characters rather than the protagonist Django. In the film, Django is freed however, we do not gain any sense of brotherhood or motivation to free other slaves, instead it is as though once freed Django is part of the white dominant culture and continues to oppress other black slaves himself. Instead, one may take on a negotiated reading of the film and therefore align with Dr. Schultz due to his sense of brotherhood.

However, if a spectator was to adapt to the black gaze, one may align more so with the black female characters. bell hooks argued that in cinema there are no positive representations of black women, they are either presented as a portrayal of the white woman, a female slave or as a laughable character. This is evident throughout Django Unchained. For example, the character Bertina is presented as the laughable caricature. We see that she is spoken down to and lacks intelligence in comparison to other black women.
We also see Sheba, who is treated as a white woman who wears expensive clothing and lives in the luxury of Candy's home.










Firstly, we see Broomhilda, Django's wife being from a white German background and therefore associating her with the dominant white culture and dislocating her from the black culture.

We then see Bertina, who acts as a characterture for the black culture, used as a mock by the white culture.

Tuesday, 31 March 2015

Bell Hooks - Black Gaze


  • Bell Hooks - oppositional gaze -All of these attempts to stop black people from gazing produced an overwhelming longing to look, a rebellious desire, an oppositional gaze.  That is what Bell Hooks’ paper is all about.  The “gaze” has been and is a site of resistance for colonized black people globally.  
  • As spectators, black men could look at white womanhood without being murdered or lynched.  In the cinema they could enter an imaginative space of phallocentric power (which Mulvey introduced us to) that mediated racial negation.
  • Most of the black women never went to movies expecting to see ‘compelling representations of black femaleness’. Aware of the absence of black womanhood in mass media.
  • No positive representations of black women - as white women or female slaves / laughable objects


  • Black people always realised that mass-media helped maintain white supremacy by presenting white people as dominance, and black people as a mere negation


  • The only way to enjoy cinema is to igore racism and sexism - Kaplan, identify with the white women

Tuesday, 24 March 2015

How would different audiences respond to Brokeback Mountain?

Introduction:
  • Different groups and spectators will adapt to a variety of readings of the film Brokeback Mountain. Extra-textual influences will force the spectator to align with and feel allegiance to particular characters or absence of characters within the film. 
  • This may result in preferred, negotiated and oppositional readings of the film. 
  • Stuart Hall - "the way the text is received, rather than the text itself"
Paragraph one: preferred reading: 
  • Taking an intended reading of the film; agreeing with ALL of the messages encoded into the text
  • Queer Gaze: Empathy = central imagining - extra textual - based on similar experiences - Sex scene with Ennis and wife - insinuates anal sex with wife - empathy to the coming out process and oppression / having to hide true self - heterosexual spectators may not align with Ennis lack of emotional connection to family due to lack of extra textual background. 
  • Rucus - Ennis is the male dominant - Jack is the female, adapting to the stereotypical housewife role = heterosexual relationship structure
  • Butler - performance of gender - in film, a homosexual couple must match the heterosexual relationship roles or their will be gender trouble - Jack's wife is the dominant/breadwinner = gender trouble - "This ain't our fault" enforcing the theory that homosexuality is not a choice - they are oppressed by society - homosexual audience may align and feel alliegance more so here than a heterosexual audience. Although a hetereosexual audience may align with Ennis and Jack, they will not feel allegiance and central imagining due to the lack of experience in this sexuality. 

Paragraph two: Negotiated reading:
  • The viewer identifies with most of the meanings encoded within the text but does not agree with all of the messages 
  • Female oppression 
  • Kaplan - having to make a conscious decision to look through the eyes of the female in film - Sex scene with Ennis and wife - insinuates anal sex = woman has no say = male dominance and power - woman may sympathise with wives as they know that the husbands are homosexual = dramatic irony = women have no say even in a homosexual relationship 
  • Jack's wife is the worker/breadwinner = against stereotypical values of Mulvey 
  • Freud - family abandonment, absence of father figure when younger = search for male companion? - Ennis' children are a constant reminder that he cannot be with the one he loves. 
  • A woman may sympathise with Ennis and Jack more due to having an oppressed past. Especially as the film was set in the 1950s, where women were also oppressed. However, a woman may also sympathise with the wives in the film, and lack of other female characters. - Story of Earl and Rich - castration due to sexuality and female absence - father made Ennis see as a warning = Freud / damaged past. Abused childhood = fight with jack = installed from a young age 
  • Mulvey - Ennis = masculine, strong build to reinforce heterosexual relationships into the film = men may align with Ennis due to this. "No ones eating unless you're serving it" said by Ennis to wife = heterosexual relationship stereotypes, still oppressed woman = link to Butler's gender trouble / hetereosexual relationship in order for it to work - Jack cooks for Ennis. 

Friday, 13 March 2015

Homosexuality - oppressed/abnormal/treated as an illness until 1990s = modern theorists
Homosexual cinema = alternative/independent
Brokeback Mountain = first mainstream film - gay spectator can directly relate or symphasise  with the coming out process = allegiance with the characters

Judith Butler 

  • Gender in all a societal performance
  • Masculinity vs femininity 
  • Homosexuality is mimicking heterosexual relationships - butch lesbian etc = gender trouble
  • Gender trouble is created when these roles are subverted - 500 days of summer Sid and Nancy 
  • Gender trouble = doomed to fail
  • Gender trouble = hyper masculine or femininity. If this occurs the relationship is doomed to fail 

Derek Rucus 
  • Homosexual spectator is forced to become a woman subculture - lust for sexual gaze from Bond
  • Gaze upon Bond himself 
  • They become the women so that the sexual gaze from the man to the woman is then put upon to them